Same pages, same words, same photo. The only thing that changes is how the colours in your palette are used. Click into either and browse the whole site.
The direction you and your GM picked in September. The three logo colours lead: a striped rule under the menu, outlined cards, and a warm off-white page.
Open Option AThe same idea, turned down. Your muted palette tones carry the pages, the three logo colours become a thin rule and small accents, and the page sits on white.
Open Option BYou mentioned Prime has no brand guidelines. Here is a first draft of the logo, colour and type rules, pulled from what the site needed. A starting point to react to.
Open brand basicsBoth use only the colours in the palette you sent. The difference is which ones do the heavy lifting. Option B is the one I would put live, because it holds up better on the long pages and keeps the photos as the loudest thing on screen.